Not Everyone Lived in Castles in the Middle Ages: A problem of chronology, or high-jacking an era

Not Everyone Lived in Castles During the Middle Ages | EDSITEment.

EDSITEment! The Best of the Humanities on the Web

As a home schooling mom who is writing our curriculum, just as I did when I was teaching, I nonetheless highly value quality lesson plans with useful resources to enhance what I am doing.  I love, LOVE, EDSITEment! as a hub of humanities lessons–particularly for its English literature lesson plans.

It has some great history and social studies plans–especially if you are looking for American history.  We are not this year, but will begin to explore the Early Modern era and American history next year.  In so doing, we will cover both history and review this year’s civics coursework–very excited, indeed!

Visit the National Endowment for the Humanities

Having said all of that, I hit a wall with some of the medieval European lesson plans.  Now, admittedly, I need the least aid in this era because I have an M.A. in it and have taught it for some time.  Most textbooks botch the era–and every other era.  My enthusiasm rose when I saw the website’s lesson plan, “Not Everyone Lived in Castles During the Middle Ages,” but it was short-lived.

The ill-named “Middle Ages” span from roughly 500-700 (A.D.) to  roughly 1400-1600 (A.D.), depending on who’s counting.  The amount of change that takes place in the millennium is considerable!  For most of that period, Europeans do not even really have castles as we typically think of them, making the very title an unwitting challenge to medieval scholarship.

The historical era known as the Middle Ages covers nearly a thousand years, stretching from the fall of Rome in the 5th century CE through the Renaissance in the 15th century CE. During much of this time fighting and warfare were rampant, and the castle, defended by armies of fearless knights, stood as a bastion of security. Medieval society was organized into a pyramid of feudal relationships, with the king and his nobles at the top and the hard-working peasants comprising the bulk of the population. Those among the peasants who were particularly talented became specialists, such as blacksmiths, fletchers, and coopers. The Middle Ages is also known as the Age of Faith, since the Catholic Church dominated the lives of rich and poor.

~ “Preparation Instructions” for the lesson plan.

American textbooks, lesson plans and other resources often lump characteristics of this millennium together without distinguishing the changes or paying attention to chronology.  The above statement is not a particularly helpful description of one thousand years of history–and, one can’t really expect it to be successful, anyway.  Yes, there was quite a bit of warfare, but it is actually far more rampant in the Early Modern era thanks to advances in weaponry which empowered the soldier over the knight, in infrastructure for the movement of troops, and in urbanization in a more densely populated Europe.  Try comparing the medieval Hundred Years War with the Napoleonic conquests and its quickly apparent that the medieval era gets the rep that the Early Modern era deserves.

The above excerpt, furthermore, is proof that quite likely no other “era” is more constrained by outdated scholarship.  Consider some examples:

  • [Specifically in reference to the above statement:] The Church was able to maintain a greater amount of continuity in Europe than any secular group until the emergence of proto-nations, but its secular, centralized authority is pretty limited until the Late Middle Ages, beginning in the 11th century, but slowly.
  • Recent scholarship (and by “recent scholarship” I mean that which began about 5 decades ago–if the debate interests you here is an introduction) has challenged the extremely simplistic “feudal pyramid” that was likely invented by Early Modern lawyers, well after the supposed system would have existed.
  • Related to the above point, while at times in the medieval millennium there was an attempt to simplify humans into easy categories, no society is so simply described as the above blurb attempts to do with medieval society.  Despite this, there is a prevalent attitude, one step beyond the notion that everyone lived in castles, that medieval society from the last Roman emperor until Leonardo Da Vinci is just that simple.

Now, in fairness, the above lesson plan is categorized in the age group for grades 3-5.  So, one might argue that this is precisely the age group who might think of everyone being a knight or a princess and living in a castle, but the concepts–even the accurate ones–which they are attempting to share are pretty narrowly confined to a small portion at the end of that millennium.  No chronology is provided.

The resources provided to the teachers include a quality link to Paul Halsall’s, “Introduction to Medieval History,” though it is only one half of a dialogue as this site was developed for a class he taught.  The elementary teacher will not have access to his lectures, nor likely all of his texts without going to a university library.  Power to the 3rd-5th grade teacher who actually does that, because it will only take scanning his course breakdown to realize something does not add up with the lesson plan’s design.  My personal experience with 3rd-5th grade teachers as a student and parent–and, I had a couple of great ones–is that they won’t “take” Halsall’s course.

Alas.  The medieval era seems doomed to be misunderstood.  It is fascinating, but few take the time to get beyond Enlightenment-era conceptions of the past between ancient Rome and the self-titled Renaissance era that is itself far more medieval than its patrons, artists and authors appreciated.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Historian's Journal

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s